Food, Pizza, St. George LA

7 Delicious Reasons Prince St. Pizza Just Became My Favorite Slice in St. George, LA

Prince St. Pizza just landed in St. George, LA, and after visiting the soft opening yesterday, I’m convinced this spot is about to ruin all other pizza for me - and that's saying something for a guy who is a self-proclaimed pizza nerd.

1. Sicilian Squares That Are Crispy, Chewy, and Totally Addictive

Prince St. is famous for its thick, square Sicilian slices, and the St. George location absolutely lives up to the hype. The crust is that perfect trifecta: crisp on the bottom, airy in the middle, and sturdy enough to hold generous toppings without getting soggy. Every bite has a satisfying crunch, then a soft, chewy center that keeps you going back for “just one more” square.

If you like your pizza bold, this is your lane. The sauce leans rich and tomato-forward, the cheese is bubbly and slightly caramelized at the edges, and the whole slice feels like it was engineered for maximum flavor (and minimal regrets).

2. Neapolitan-Style Rounds for the Classic Pizza Lover

Prefer something a little lighter and more traditional? Their Neapolitan-style round pies are the perfect counterpoint to the hearty Sicilian slices. The crust is thinner, with a gentle chew and those beautiful, slightly blistered edges that make you want to eat every last piece of the cornicione (yes, even the “I don’t eat crust” people will cave here).

The Neapolitan options really showcase the balance of sauce, cheese, and dough. Nothing feels heavy or overloaded. Instead, each pie has a clean, focused flavor profile that makes it easy to share a few different varieties at the table (and sample everyone else’s slice, obviously).

3. A Lineup of Pizza Varieties That Makes Choosing Hard (In a Fun Way)

One of the best parts of Prince St. Pizza is the variety. From the classics to the over-the-top, the menu is built for both purists and adventurers. Think:

• Simple cheese slices that remind you why you fell in love with pizza in the first place,

• Pepperoni-heavy options with those famous “cup and char” edges that crisp up just right,

• Veggie-forward pies that still feel indulgent (not like an obligation),

• Specialty combos loaded with flavor, without turning into a chaotic pile of toppings.

You can taste that every variety has been tested, tweaked, and perfected. Nothing feels random; everything feels intentional (and seriously tasty).

Mixing Sicilian squares and Neapolitan rounds makes sharing (and sampling) way more fun.

4. A Menu That Goes Beyond “Just a Slice”

While the pizza is the star, the menu options at Prince St. Pizza round out the experience. You’ll find shareable starters, fresh salads to balance out the cheese party, and enough combinations to keep repeat visits interesting. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch slice, planning a casual date night, or feeding a group, the menu feels flexible and welcoming.

It’s the kind of place where you can build your own lineup—maybe a classic cheese round, a couple of loaded Sicilian squares, something spicy, something simple—and everyone at the table leaves happy (and plotting their next order).

5. Sicilian vs. Neapolitan: Why You Should Try Both

If you’re new to the Sicilian and Neapolitan styles, Prince St. Pizza is a fun (and delicious) crash course. The Sicilian slices are thick, square, and unapologetically hearty—ideal when you want something filling with serious crunch and chew. The Neapolitan-style rounds are thinner, lighter, and all about balance, with a softer center and airy crust bubbles around the edge.

Ordering one of each style side by side is the move. You get to experience how the same sauce and toppings transform across different doughs and textures. By the end, you’ll probably have a favorite—but honestly, “both” is a perfectly acceptable answer.

6. A Neighborhood Spot With Big-City Flavor

Even at the soft opening, the energy at the St. George location felt warm, relaxed, and genuinely excited. The team was friendly and helpful, happy to explain the different styles and suggest slices if you froze up at the counter (decision paralysis is real when everything looks good). It already feels like the kind of place you swing by after work, before a game, or anytime a serious pizza craving hits.

7. Final Verdict: My New Go-To Pizza in Town

After just one visit, Prince St. Pizza has officially rocketed to the top of my St. George pizza list. The variety of pizzas, the thoughtful menu options, and the chance to enjoy both Sicilian and Neapolitan styles in one place make it an easy recommendation for anyone who loves a great slice.

If you’re in St. George, LA, and even mildly pizza-obsessed, put this spot at the top of your “must-try” list. Show up hungry, bring friends, and don’t be shy about ordering more than you think you need—you’ll want those leftovers later.